IRR, Equity Multiple, and Cash-on-Cash Return: How Private Real Estate Returns Are Measured
On this page
- IRR Meaning: How the Internal Rate of Return Works
- Equity Multiple and MOIC: How Much Comes Back per Dollar
- Cash-on-Cash Return and Distribution Yield
- Annualized Return (CAGR) and How It Differs From IRR
- IRR vs. Equity Multiple: A Worked Example With the Same 1.5x
- How the Five Return Metrics Compare
- Where Return Metrics Mislead: Limits and Pitfalls
- Questions to Ask a Sponsor About Any Return Figure
- Frequently Asked Questions About IRR, Equity Multiple, and Cash-on-Cash Return
- Rebuild the IRR From Your Own Cash Flow Dates
- References
Private real estate returns are usually reported with three numbers. The internal rate of return (IRR) is an annualized rate that accounts for when each dollar goes in and comes out. The equity multiple, also called MOIC (multiple on invested capital), divides everything returned, plus any remaining value, by the equity invested, with no adjustment for time. Cash-on-cash return compares one year’s cash distributions with the cash invested.
Each answers a different question: how fast capital grew, how much it grew, and how much cash it paid along the way. All three depend on whether a figure is projected or realized, gross or net of fees, and which dates and cash flows went into it.
This guide explains how each metric is calculated, how the equity multiple relates to the TVPI and DPI figures in fund reports, works through a dollar example, and lists the questions to ask a sponsor about any return figure.
IRR Meaning: How the Internal Rate of Return Works
The internal rate of return is the discount rate at which the net present value of all of an investment’s cash flows equals zero. SEC staff guidance describes a private fund’s IRR the same way, using every cash flow over the fund’s life.1
With CF0 as the initial investment (negative) and CF1 through CFn as later distributions (positive) or contributions (negative), IRR is the rate that solves:
0 = CF0 + CF1 ÷ (1 + IRR) + CF2 ÷ (1 + IRR)² + … + CFn ÷ (1 + IRR)ⁿ
Excel’s IRR function solves this iteratively from a starting guess and assumes the cash flows fall at regular intervals, such as monthly or annually.2 Its XIRR function uses actual dates and discounts each payment on a 365-day year.3
IRR is a money-weighted return, the term the CFA Institute’s Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) use for a return that reflects the timing and size of cash flows.4 IRR measures speed; it says nothing about how many dollars were earned.
Equity Multiple and MOIC: How Much Comes Back per Dollar
The equity multiple measures total return in dollars per dollar invested:
Equity multiple = (Total distributions + Remaining value) ÷ Equity invested
Turning $100,000 into $150,000 of total distributions is a 1.5x multiple: $1.50 back per dollar, including the dollar itself. At 1.0x the investor gets the money back with no profit.
MOIC is the same arithmetic, but the labels tend to follow the level of measurement. Guidance for the performance template that the Institutional Limited Partners Association (ILPA) released in January 2025 notes that most private fund managers present gross IRR and MOIC from cash flows between a fund and its investments, and net IRR and TVPI from cash flows between the fund and its investors.5
How the Equity Multiple Relates to TVPI and DPI
Fund reports split the equity multiple into realized and unrealized parts. GIPS defines each ratio against since-inception paid-in capital, the capital investors have contributed.4
- DPI (distributions to paid-in capital), the realization multiple: distributions ÷ paid-in capital.
- RVPI (residual value to paid-in capital), the unrealized multiple: remaining value of investors’ interest ÷ paid-in capital.
- TVPI (total value to paid-in capital), the investment multiple: distributions plus residual value ÷ paid-in capital, so TVPI equals DPI plus RVPI.
GIPS-compliant firms that report money-weighted returns for a fund with committed capital must present all three.4
Suppose an investor in a private real estate fund has paid in $100,000, received $30,000 of distributions and holds an interest the manager values at $95,000. DPI is 0.30x, RVPI is 0.95x and TVPI is 1.25x. Only the 0.30x is cash in hand; the rest is an estimate until the properties sell.
Cash-on-Cash Return and Distribution Yield
Cash-on-cash return measures one year’s cash relative to the cash invested:
Cash-on-cash return = Annual pre-tax cash distributions ÷ Cash invested
If a $100,000 investment distributes $6,000 in a year, its cash-on-cash return is 6% for that year. Definitions vary: some sponsors use property cash flow after debt service, others the cash actually distributed, and the denominator may be original equity or only the capital still invested.
Distribution yield, often called the distribution rate, annualizes the current distribution, such as $1,500 a quarter, and divides it by the capital invested or by current value.
Both leave out appreciation and sale proceeds and count every distribution alike, whatever its source. FINRA’s guidance to broker-dealers notes that some real estate programs fund part of their distributions with return of principal or loan proceeds, and it bars member firms from stating or implying that a distribution rate is a “yield” or “current yield.”6
Annualized Return (CAGR) and How It Differs From IRR
An annualized return converts a total gain into a constant yearly rate, usually as a compound annual growth rate (CAGR):
Annualized return (CAGR) = (Ending value ÷ Beginning value)^(1 ÷ years) − 1
CAGR uses two points, the starting and ending values. IRR uses every dated cash flow in between, so the two match when there is a single contribution and a single payout and diverge once interim cash flows appear.
Watch for two shortcuts. A simple average, such as $50,000 of profit over five years described as 10% a year, overstates the compound rate of about 8.4% a year that grows $100,000 into $150,000 in five years. Annualizing a short holding period magnifies small gains, and GIPS prohibits annualizing returns for periods of less than one year.4
IRR vs. Equity Multiple: A Worked Example With the Same 1.5x
The following is illustrative arithmetic for two hypothetical investments. Each takes $100,000 and returns $150,000 in total over five years. Investment A distributes $6,000 a year and returns $120,000 from a sale at the end of Year 5. Investment B distributes nothing until its sale returns $150,000 at the end of Year 5.
| Cash flow to the investor | Investment A | Investment B |
|---|---|---|
| Year 0 (investment) | −$100,000 | −$100,000 |
| Years 1 to 4 (each year) | $6,000 | $0 |
| Year 5 | $126,000 ($6,000 plus $120,000 from the sale) | $150,000 (sale) |
| Total distributions | $150,000 | $150,000 |
| Equity multiple | 1.5x | 1.5x |
| IRR (XIRR, annual dates) | About 9.3% | About 8.4% |
| Cash returned before Year 5 | $24,000 (0.24x DPI) | $0 |
| Cash-on-cash, Years 1 to 4 | 6% each year | 0% |
Equity multiple. Both earn $50,000 of profit and a 1.5x multiple.
IRR. Investment A has the higher IRR: about 9.3% a year, against about 8.4% for B, calculated with Excel’s XIRR function on annual dates.3 It receives $24,000 in Years 1 through 4, while all of B’s cash arrives at the end, and IRR gives more weight to dollars received sooner. With no interim cash flows, B’s IRR equals its annualized return.
Cash-on-cash. A pays 6% each year; B pays nothing until the sale.
Conclusion. Investment A returned cash sooner, 24% of its capital before the sale year against nothing for B, and that earlier cash is what gives A the higher IRR. Less of A’s outcome rides on the sale price. The early cash is worth only what the investor does with it: held in an account earning nothing, A’s distributions would leave the investor with $150,000 at the end of Year 5, the same as B.
How the Five Return Metrics Compare
| Metric | What it measures | Accounts for time? | Includes sale proceeds or appreciation? | What it misses | Most useful for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IRR | Rate that sets the net present value of all cash flows to zero | Yes, every dated cash flow | Yes, plus any remaining value | Dollar size of the profit; sensitivity to dates and credit lines | Comparing investments with different cash flow timing |
| Equity multiple (MOIC, TVPI) | Distributions plus remaining value per dollar invested | No | Yes | How long the money was tied up | Total profit per dollar, read with IRR |
| Cash-on-cash return | One year’s pre-tax cash distributions per dollar invested | One year at a time | No | Sale proceeds, appreciation, and whether cash is returned capital | Current income from a stabilized property |
| Distribution yield | Annualized distributions relative to capital or current value | A current snapshot | No | Source of the cash; total return | Tracking an income stream over time |
| Annualized return (CAGR) | Constant yearly rate from a starting to an ending value | Yes, between two points | Yes, through the ending value | Interim distributions and later contributions | Lump-sum investments; public-market comparisons |
Where Return Metrics Mislead: Limits and Pitfalls
Sensitivity to Timing
Because IRR annualizes, timing alone can move it a long way. Turning $100,000 into $110,000 in six months produces a higher IRR than turning $100,000 into $150,000 over five years, although the second earns five times as many dollars. Measuring from the property closing instead of the date capital was called also changes IRR without changing profit. ILPA’s template guidance dates each cash flow on the day the cash moved, which for a capital call is its due date.5
Early Distributions and Partial Returns of Capital
Anything that returns cash sooner raises IRR, including distributions that are largely the investor’s own capital. Take Investment C, a variation on A: a Year 2 refinancing funds an extra $40,000 distribution, higher loan payments cut later distributions to $4,000 a year, and the sale nets $86,000. C’s cash flows are $6,000, $46,000, $4,000, $4,000 and $90,000, the same $150,000 total and 1.5x multiple.
With 60% of its capital back by the end of Year 4, C’s IRR, about 11.5%, beats A’s on the same profit, its Year 2 cash-on-cash return of 46% is mostly borrowed money, and the property carries more debt. ILPA has separately advised managers against using subscription lines to fund distributions ahead of an exit.7
Subscription Lines of Credit
A subscription line is a fund-level loan secured by investors’ unfunded capital commitments.1 When a fund buys property with the line and calls capital months later, investors’ money is out for less time and, for a profitable investment, their IRR rises, though the property performs the same. ILPA’s 2017 guidance says this shortens the J-curve and enhances IRR, most of all early in a fund’s life.7 Interest and fees cut total dollars: in ILPA’s simplified example, delaying the first capital call by one year and then two raised IRR from 6.62% to 7.14% to 7.98%, while TVPI fell from 1.45x to 1.40x to 1.35x.7
ILPA recommends that managers report net IRR with and without the facility.7 GIPS reports that show money-weighted returns must present them with and without the line, unless its principal was repaid within 120 days using called capital and none of it funded distributions.4 SEC staff consider it a marketing rule violation to compare a gross IRR calculated without a subscription line only to a net IRR calculated with one.1
The Reinvestment Assumption and Modified IRR
Aswath Damodaran’s corporate finance text describes IRR as implicitly assuming that interim cash flows are reinvested at the IRR itself.8 If distributions earn less, the return actually achieved falls below the IRR even when every cash flow arrives as planned, and the gap widens with a higher IRR, a longer hold and earlier payouts.8
Modified IRR (MIRR) compounds interim cash flows at a chosen rate, such as the return the investor could realistically earn elsewhere, before solving for the return.8 Excel’s MIRR function takes both a finance rate and a reinvestment rate.9 At a reinvestment rate of zero, MIRR puts Investments A and B level, because A’s distributions still total $150,000 by Year 5.
Multiple IRRs When Cash Flows Change Sign
A conventional investment has one sign change, money in and then money out, and a single IRR. When the stream changes sign more than once, the equation can have more than one solution, and it is unclear which to use.10 Long-lived projects often need substantial reinvestment partway through, which can turn cash flows negative again.10 In real estate, that might be a capital call for a renovation after years of distributions.
Excel’s IRR function starts from a guess and returns one answer; Microsoft suggests trying a different guess if the result looks wrong.2 Damodaran’s text concludes that the simpler course is to use net present value at a stated discount rate.10
Projected Versus Realized Returns
A projected or targeted IRR rests on assumptions about rents, expenses, financing, holding period and exit price; a realized IRR uses cash that changed hands. Any IRR or TVPI calculated before the final sale includes an estimate of remaining value.
The SEC marketing rule treats targeted or projected returns as hypothetical performance. A registered adviser may advertise them only if it adopts policies designed to keep them relevant to the intended audience, explains the criteria and assumptions behind them, and provides, or for private fund investors offers to provide promptly, information on their risks and limitations.11 GIPS recommends an external valuation of private market investments at least every 12 months, and GIPS fund reports must show the share of assets valued with subjective, unobservable inputs when that share is material.4
Gross Versus Net of Fees and Carried Interest
Gross performance is measured before the fees and expenses an investor pays for the adviser’s services, and net performance after them.11 GIPS counts carried interest, also called the promote, as an investment management fee, so net-of-fees returns reflect the sponsor’s profit share.4 The gap matters most when a gross, deal-level MOIC or IRR sits beside an investor’s net result in a syndication or a fund. Our guide to how equity funds work in private real estate shows how a distribution waterfall splits profit between investors and the sponsor.
The marketing rule, 17 CFR 275.206(4)-1, applies to investment advisers registered, or required to be registered, with the SEC under section 203 of the Investment Advisers Act.11 Their advertisements may show gross performance only alongside net performance of at least equal prominence, in a format designed for comparison, over the same period and with the same type of return and methodology.11 In March 2025, SEC staff said they would not recommend enforcement action when a single investment’s gross figure appears without its own net figure, under conditions that include showing the total portfolio’s gross and net performance with at least equal prominence.1 A sponsor that is neither registered nor required to register with the SEC as an adviser is outside this rule, so ask how its figures are built.
Return of Capital Versus Return on Capital
A return of capital gives back money you invested; a return on capital is profit. Distribution checks look the same either way, and cash-on-cash and distribution yield count both alike.
The SEC’s 2015 investor bulletin on non-traded REITs warns that distributions may come from offering proceeds, including investors’ own money, or from borrowings, which reduces share value and the cash available to buy property.12 When a quoted distribution rate includes principal or borrowings, FINRA’s guidance calls for a broker-dealer’s presentation to break out the shares from operations, principal and borrowings and to disclose, among other points, that returning principal leaves less to invest, which may lower the overall return.6
Questions to Ask a Sponsor About Any Return Figure
Before relying on any return figure, ask:
- Projected or realized? If projected, which rent, expense, financing and exit assumptions drive it? If realized, through what date, and how much of the multiple is DPI?
- Gross or net? Net of which fees, expenses and carried interest? Is it the fund’s return to investors or one deal’s gross return?
- Which dates and cash flows? Does the IRR start at the property closing or when capital was called? Were actual dates used?
- Was a credit facility used? What is the IRR with and without the subscription line, and did borrowing fund any distributions?
- How was unrealized value estimated? Who valued the remaining properties, as of what date, and with what method and assumptions?
- What funded the distributions? How much came from operations, and how much from refinancing, reserves, sale proceeds or returned capital?
- Which standard applies? Is the sponsor an SEC-registered adviser, and does it claim GIPS compliance?
Frequently Asked Questions About IRR, Equity Multiple, and Cash-on-Cash Return
What does IRR mean in real estate?
IRR stands for internal rate of return, the annualized discount rate at which the present value of an investment’s distributions equals the present value of its contributions. It reflects both how much cash comes back and when, and earlier cash raises it.
What is a good equity multiple?
There is no universal benchmark. A multiple means little without the time it took, the risk and leverage involved, and whether it is gross or net of fees. The same 1.5x is a different result over three years than over ten.
What is the difference between IRR and MOIC?
MOIC, or multiple on invested capital, measures dollars returned per dollar invested, without regard to time. IRR measures the annualized rate implied by the timing of every cash flow. Two investments with the same MOIC can have very different IRRs.
Is the equity multiple the same as TVPI?
They use the same arithmetic: distributions plus remaining value, divided by the capital invested. In fund reporting, TVPI is usually net of fees and shown with DPI, its cash-only portion, while sponsors often quote MOIC gross at the deal level.
How do you calculate cash-on-cash return?
Divide one year’s pre-tax cash distributions by the cash invested. A $6,000 distribution on a $100,000 investment is a 6% cash-on-cash return for that year. The figure ignores sale proceeds and appreciation and treats returned capital like income.
What is distribution yield?
Distribution yield, or distribution rate, is the current annualized distribution divided by the capital invested or by current value. It shows the size of the income stream without showing its source, which can include returned principal or borrowed money.
Why can IRR be misleading?
IRR is highly sensitive to timing. Early distributions, partial returns of capital, short holding periods and subscription credit lines can all raise it without adding a dollar of profit. It also implicitly assumes distributions are reinvested at the IRR.
What is the difference between IRR and annualized return?
An annualized return, or CAGR, is the constant yearly rate that turns a starting value into an ending value, using only those two points. IRR accounts for every cash flow in between. With one investment and one payout they are equal.
Rebuild the IRR From Your Own Cash Flow Dates
Every figure in this guide can be rebuilt from one schedule: the date and amount of each contribution and distribution, plus the reported value of what remains. Ask the sponsor for it, or build it from your capital account statements.
Enter contributions as negatives, distributions as positives and the remaining value as a final positive amount on the statement date, then run XIRR on the actual dates. Distributions divided by contributions give DPI; adding the remaining value before dividing gives TVPI.
Your result reflects the dates your capital was actually called, which is how a fund’s net IRR is typically measured when it includes the effect of a subscription line.5 If the sponsor’s headline figure is higher, ask whether it is gross, deal-level or for another fee class. Then ask for the IRR without the subscription line; the gap between that figure and yours shows how much of your return came from delayed capital calls.
References
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — “Marketing Compliance – Frequently Asked Questions.” Division of Investment Management staff FAQs on the marketing rule, including the February 2024 answer on gross and net IRR with subscription facilities and the March 2025 answer on extracted performance.
- Microsoft — “IRR function.” Excel documentation for IRR, covering regular-interval cash flows, the iterative calculation and the optional starting guess.
- Microsoft — “XIRR function.” Excel documentation for XIRR, which calculates IRR for dated cash flows that are not necessarily periodic, using a 365-day year.
- CFA Institute — “Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) for Firms 2020.” The 2020 edition of the GIPS standards, with money-weighted return rules, the TVPI, DPI, RVPI and PIC multiples, subscription line provisions and the glossary.
- Institutional Limited Partners Association — “Performance Template Guidance – Granular Methodology.” Guidance for ILPA’s Performance Template, released in January 2025, on fund-level and portfolio-level IRR, TVPI and MOIC, subscription facilities and cash flow dates.
- FINRA — “Regulatory Notice 13-18: FINRA Provides Guidance on Communications With the Public Concerning Unlisted Real Estate Investment Programs.” May 2013 guidance to broker-dealers on presenting distribution rates, including distributions funded by return of principal or borrowings.
- Institutional Limited Partners Association — “Subscription Lines of Credit and Alignment of Interests: Considerations and Best Practices for Limited and General Partners.” ILPA’s June 2017 guidance on how subscription lines affect IRR and TVPI, with recommended disclosures and practices.
- Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern School of Business — “Chapter 6: Project Interactions, Side Costs, and Side Benefits.” Corporate finance textbook chapter on the reinvestment rate assumptions behind NPV and IRR and on the modified internal rate of return.
- Microsoft — “MIRR function.” Excel documentation for the modified internal rate of return, which takes a finance rate and a reinvestment rate.
- Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern School of Business — “Chapter 5: Measuring Return on Investments.” Corporate finance textbook chapter on NPV and IRR, including why cash flows that change sign more than once can produce multiple IRRs.
- Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School — “17 CFR § 275.206(4)-1 – Investment adviser marketing.” Text of the SEC marketing rule, including its scope, the net performance requirement and the definitions of gross, net and hypothetical performance.
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov — “Investor Bulletin: Non-traded REITs.” August 2015 SEC investor bulletin warning that non-traded REIT distributions may be paid from offering proceeds or borrowings.
This article is for educational purposes only. Novacrest offerings are available to verified accredited investors through official offering documents. Nothing in this article constitutes investment, legal, tax, or financial advice. Private real estate investments involve risk, including possible loss of principal. Prospective investors should review all offering documents and consult their own attorney, accountant, and financial adviser before investing.
This article is provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be relied upon for investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing in this article constitutes an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. Any such offer or solicitation will be made only through a formal Private Placement Memorandum (PPM) or other authorized offering documents provided to qualified accredited investors, in accordance with applicable securities laws. Any estimates, projections, or forward-looking statements are inherently uncertain and subject to risks that may cause actual results to differ materially. Past performance does not indicate future success. You should consult with your own attorneys, accountants, and financial advisors before making any investment decisions.